Is an automatic dispenser better than a regular one? Analysis

Comparison of automatic (touchless) dispensers with traditional (manual) ones involves several important aspects that affect their usefulness in different contexts. Analysis of these devices in terms of hygiene, economy, and functionality shows that each of them has its own advantages and disadvantages, depending on the priorities of users and the place of application.

Hygiene

Touchless soap dispensers provide the highest standard of hygiene, which is their most important advantage. Thanks to the use of motion sensors, users do not have to touch the surface of the dispenser, minimizing the risk of transferring bacteria and viruses. This is particularly important in public places such as toilets, schools, hospitals, or offices, where many people are present every day. Automatic dispensers eliminate the problem of cross-contamination, which is difficult to achieve with traditional dispensers that require pressing a pump.

High-quality automatic metal soap dispensers, usually made of stainless steel, offer exceptional advantages in terms of functionality and aesthetics. First and foremost, their durability is one of the key benefits - stainless steel is resistant to corrosion and mechanical damage, making these devices perfect for heavily used places such as public toilets or kitchens. Another important feature is high hygiene, provided by their touchless operation, eliminating the risk of contact with bacteria. Metal dispensers are also easy to clean, which further increases their sanitary qualities. Additionally, these devices are characterized by a modern and elegant design, which blends perfectly with high-end interiors.

Economy

In terms of economics, both automatic and traditional dispensers have their advantages and disadvantages. Automatic models often dispense soap in precise amounts, which reduces its consumption and thus lowers costs in the long run. Additionally, the possibility of using foaming soap in some automatic dispensers further increases savings, as foaming soap is more efficient.

Purchase cost

1. Automatic dispenser:
   • The cost of automatic dispensers is significantly higher than their traditional counterparts. Prices start at around 200-300 PLN for simpler models, and more advanced devices, especially those made of metal or equipped with additional features (such as LED sensors or soap quantity adjustment), can cost up to 500-1000 PLN(
     
   •  In the case of dispensers for commercial use (e.g. in offices, schools), prices can be even higher, reaching 1500 PLN(
2. Traditional dispenser:
   • Traditional manual dispensers are much cheaper. The simplest models can be purchased for as little as a few to several dozen zlotys. Even more stylish dispensers, made of more durable materials, rarely exceed 100-200 zł.

Operating costs

1. Automatic dispenser:
   • The main operating cost of automatic dispensers is battery replacement, which can be inconvenient, especially in high-traffic areas. The frequency of battery replacement depends on usage intensity, but usually AAA or AA batteries last for several months.
   • At the same time, automatic dispensers often have a precise dosing function, which allows saving soap by reducing its excessive consumption. Models with a foam dosing function further increase savings.
2. Traditional dispenser:
   • Traditional dispensers do not require additional costs related to power supply, making them cheaper to operate. On the other hand, due to manual dosing, it is more difficult to control the amount of soap dispensed, which can lead to greater product consumption.

Maintenance costs and reliability

1. Automatic dispenser:
   • Automatic models are more prone to failures related to electronics (e.g. sensor problems, leaks, power failures), which may require servicing or even replacement of the device.
     This generates additional costs compared to simpler, manual models.
2. Traditional dispenser:
   • Manual dispensers are less prone to failures due to their simple construction, which means they do not require frequent repairs. Therefore, the service costs for them are minimal.

Functionality

In terms of functionality, automatic soap dispensers offer modern solutions that increase user comfort. Built-in motion sensors allow for easy and quick soap dispensing, which is particularly important in places with high traffic. Some models are equipped with additional features, such as adjustable soap dispensing, soap and battery level indicators, which make maintenance easier.

On the other hand, these devices are more complicated to use and may experience failures, especially when the batteries run out. Traditional dispensers are simpler and less prone to failures, and their operation does not require advanced technology, making them easier to maintain.

Summary

Both types of dispensers have their unique advantages and disadvantages, which determine their use in different situations. Automatic dispensers stand out for their high level of hygiene thanks to touchless operation, making them an ideal choice in public places where minimizing contact with surfaces is crucial. Despite higher purchase and operating costs, precise soap dispensing in these devices can bring savings in the long run. They are also more technologically advanced, offering additional features, but are also more prone to malfunctions.

On the other hand, traditional dispensers are characterized by simplicity, lower purchase cost, and no need for power supply, making them cheaper to operate. However, their manual operation, even in models with elbow levers, is not as hygienic as in the case of automatic models. In places with lower traffic, such as home bathrooms, traditional dispensers may be more suitable and sufficient.

Author: Kacper Błaszczyk

​